Category Archives: Kashmir

Does Aid Kill Development?

Published / by Jehangir

One blogger whose posts I follow regularly is Kevin Kelly. Recently I came across a thought-provoking idea in his Technium blog.

Quote:
Poverty is the natural beginning state of all societies, east or west. Rather, decentralization is the engine which removes poverty and brings wealth. To the degree that infrastructure, education, and trade can be decentralized, wealth will rise in proportion. To the degree that infrastructure, education and trade are centralized, poverty will remain.

….Wiliam Easterly argues in his book, The Elusive Quest for Growth, that the billions and billions of dollars spent on aid for developing countries has not only *not* helped, it has set them back decades. Aid, as we know it, kills development. This harm occurs because almost all previous aid has funneled through a central government or semi-governmental organizations and that official route tightens centrality. Even if the governments were saintly, and they are definitely not, the scale of money flowing through these centralizing nodes prohibits the distribution of resources, infrastructure, trade, and education. The more aid that arrives, the less development can actually happen.
Unquote.

In Kashmir I feel that the problem is that all very often the motives behind providing aid are not entirely altruistic. Aid is more like largesse distributed according to a specific agenda of either the provider [aid agency] or the implementer [government agency/NGO] with the result that that aid-based development is skewed, even though it can be argued that it may be better than no development at all.

KK also has some interesting photos of Kashmir in his photogallery.
Well worth a visit.

150 not out (WildKashmir)

Published / by Jehangir

Kashmir

This weekend I recorded the 150th bird species I have personally observed in Kashmir. This checklist is based on birds I have observed in the valley and positively identified. The list includes some rarities like the Kashmir Nuthatch, Isabelline Wheatear, Black Stork and Chaffinch (the first ever sighting in Kashmir).

If there is any element of doubt regarding the identification the sightings have not been included in this list. AFAIK this is the most comprehensive list of confirmed bird sightings in Kashmir. For the record the 150th bird species was the Ferruginous Pochard.

Ferruginous

Here is a list of the 20 commonest birds of Kashmir. This is a really fast photogallery of the Birds of Kashmir.

P.S The checklist now stands at 172 confirmed sightings (2018). Watch this space.


Image copyright Dr. Bakshi Jehangir. All rights reserved.

Christmas in Hokersar (Wild Kashmir)

Published / by Jehangir

Record numbers of migratory waterfowl have been sighted in Kashmir's wetlands this year.

On Christmas Day, I observed a multitude of migratory ducks like mallards, teals, shovellers, gadwalls, pochards, etc and a few flocks of Greylag Geese and Ruddy Shelducks at the Hokersar sanctuary. The highlight of the trip were the endangered Pallas's Fishing Eagles soaring majestically in the sky.

Efforts being made to improve Hokersar are immediately noticeable. Leaky, dilapidated boats have been converted into smart houseboats, observation platforms have been repaired and new ones added, pools cleared and flagged.

I had the chance to interact with Dr. Mir Mansoor, the Chief Wildlife Biologist who was monitoring the wetland for evidence of Bird Flu. We had a very interesting discussion on a variety of topics related to wildlife and Kashmir's fragile ecology. Clearly he and Kashmir's Wildlife Warden, Abdul Rauf Zargar take their responsibilities very seriously. More power to them.


P.S: Who gave permission for a housing colony on the highway adjoining Hokersar? The Hokersar Sanctuary is rapidly being degraded for a number of reasons and might not last in its present form for very long. This fresh assault may be the final nail in its coffin.

2006

2007

News Links:
6 lakh avian guests arrive in valley
Incessant silt deposition poses major threat to Hokersar